Scott Hayes, a 47-year-old Iraq War veteran, was arraigned and released on a $5,000 bail after being arrested for shooting a man who tackled him during a protest in Newton, Massachusetts.
The incident occurred when Caleb Gannon, wearing a pro-Palestinian pin, charged across traffic and physically attacked Hayes, who had been peacefully demonstrating with American and Israeli flags. Hayes, in an act of self-defense, shot Gannon in the stomach during the altercation.
In court, Hayes pleaded not guilty to the charge of assault and battery with a dangerous weapon. The judge ordered him to wear a GPS ankle monitor and abide by a curfew, but permitted him to continue working as a contractor.
Hayes’ defense also requested allowances for attending religious services and medical appointments, a point briefly touched upon in his court appearance.
Although District Attorney Marian Ryan suggested additional charges, including violation of a constitutional right causing injury, only the charge of assault and battery with a dangerous weapon was formally brought during the arraignment. Prosecutors have also moved for a criminal complaint against Gannon, the man who tackled Hayes, which is still pending in the court’s clerk office.
The incident, which was captured on video, shows Gannon aggressively confronting a group of pro-Israel demonstrators before tackling Hayes. While Gannon was on top of him, Hayes, who legally owned the firearm, shot Gannon in the stomach. The video also depicts Hayes calmly setting his weapon aside and calling for help, asking bystanders to contact emergency services while tending to Gannon’s wound.
The case has drawn widespread public attention, with a GoFundMe campaign raising over $130,000 for Hayes’ legal defense. Supporters, including the Republican Jewish Coalition, have rallied behind Hayes, portraying him as a man who defended himself against a violent attack.
Others, such as the Anti-Defamation League New England, have raised concerns over the rapid filing of charges before the investigation was completed.
Hayes is a frequent attendee at pro-Israel rallies throughout New England, advocating for Israel and calling for the release of hostages currently held by Hamas in Gaza. As the legal proceedings continue, the case highlights the rising tensions and political divides in protests across the country.